The Five Killers of On-Time Delivery

Why that great plan on paper never quite pans out.

Photo by Andy Beales on Unsplash

You’ve been in that meeting. A project is starting to run off the rails so the project manager calls a “How Do We Right the Ship?” gathering. Gantt charts are at every desk and red pens are feverishly working. Ideas pour in and a new plan is unfurled. Smiles abound and verbally backslapping fills the room. The project that looked like it was destined to ship in June has been pulled into April.

Flash forward to June and everyone is scrambling to make delivery by the end of the month. What happened?

What gets measured gets improved.

A project manager, by definition, is managing via influence. A functional manager, by defintion, is managing via authority.

When these two management influences collide, the functional manager always wins that war. But in a matrix organization how can the functional manager be empowered to meet the required schedule while respecting a project manager’s needs? Too often that functional manager is managing by the greatest urgency, moving from project to project as noise is created by the responsible project manager.

In most organizations there is a weekly gathering involving the functional manager and team. However, plans shift drastically, and daily, regimented check-ins may be just the cure for the madness. Does a daily measure sound too extreme? An exhaustive study by the American Psychological Association shows that daily monitoring of schedules clearly improves outcomes. Furthermore, additional benefit can be obtained by publically reporting progress.

This is where tools like a daily GEMBA walk prove their usefulness. Psychologically humans are wired to take action on what is visible. Putting too much onus on the project manager for keeping a schedule overstresses a single contributor unnecessarily and is not a substitute for a functional team that has daily awareness of their goals.

Estimates are based on the Most Likely Scenario

The fallacy of estimates is easily exposed by this example. If everything goes right, a few hours can be saved. But a few flies in the ointment and a task can easily push out days or weeks. This scenario sounds way too familiar to those who manage projects.

The Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) was developed to shed light on this fallacy. PERT takes a typical estimate and weighs it according to the most likely outcome. The calculation is as follows:

Pert Estimate = (Optimistic + (4 X Most Likely) + Pessimistic)/6.

In the engineering calculation example, the 8 hour task under PERT becomes a 9 hour estimate. This is a subtle, but highly important difference. A PERT estimate, whether roughed out by hard or done via software, will return a better result than the typical “most likely case scenario”.

Photo by Sherman Yang on Unsplash

Linear Efficiency Gains are Never Linear

Painting a picture with too broad a brushstroke is usually nipped in the bud by a well-seasoned shop foreman. However, his voice is too often drowned out by well-meaning engineers or managers. The high efficiency of top workers and physical limitations that prevent optimal work are too often overlooked.

Risk Registry is Absent

A Risk Registry never has to be an elaborate tool, and simpler is usually better. Simple Risk Registries allow any team members to contribute possible impediments during a project. Risk Registries at a minimum should include detail of the risk assessment, probability of occurrence, severity should it occur, and mitigation strategy. Download an Excel-based registry that Momenta Tech uses for all of its engagements.

Photo by Jack Sloop on Unsplash

Poor Executive Engagement

Executives can quickly refresh and inspire their team by patrolling the halls and asking project managers a simple question, “Is there anything I do to help you?” The answer from staffers typically will be “all is good” out of politeness or deference. That’s when it is time for the executive to dig deeper. “What is one thing our organization can give you to ensure your success?” The famous businessman Arnold Glagow once said:

“One of the true tests of leadership is the ability to recognize a problem before it becomes an emergency.”

This is no truer than in the world of project management. Balancing dozens of stakeholder expectations and navigating countless project impediments to deliver a project on time and on budget makes project management extremely challenging. A great project manager that is properly supported by executives is a boon to a company’s bottom line.

Photo by Dan Meyers on Unsplash

So the next time pulling that delivery date in seems so easy? Think about these five killers of on-time delivery. And before the temptation sets in to issue congrats on a project nowhere near shipment, take a deep breath and have the vision to know the next page in the story.

Written by Travis Ziebro ,a Senior Consultant with Momenta Tech. We help mid market manufacturers and distributors improve their profitability in a crazy short amount of time.

Making companies better through technology

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store